Editorial: AI and Machine Learning: Proceed with Caution | AIChE

91成人短视频

You are here

Editorial: AI and Machine Learning: Proceed with Caution

Editorial
August
2024

Emily Petruzzelli, Editor-in-Chief

One of my favorite movies growing up was Terminator 2: Judgment Day. For those unfamiliar with the Terminator movies, they center on humankind鈥檚 resistance to the rise of a malevolent artificial intelligence (AI) entity known as Skynet. Some of the largest pushback against the burgeoning use of AI is prompted by such media portrayals. But the reality is that AI has a long way to go before it can take over the world.

Compared to computers, humans excel at ignoring obviously misleading information when learning about new topics. For chatbots based on large-language models (LLMs), such distinctions are difficult. LLMs are only as reliable as the data they are fed. For example, in a popular Forbes article published in May, the author collated several examples of Google鈥檚 AI providing hilariously misleading results to simple queries. For one user who wanted to stop the cheese from sliding off of his pizza, Google鈥檚 AI Overview suggested adding 鈥渁bout 1/8 cup of non-toxic glue to the sauce to give it more tackiness,鈥 drawing from a Reddit troll post from over a decade ago.

Google is not alone when it comes to their AI product generating absurd responses. I was playing around with OpenAI鈥檚 GPT-4o 鈥 the current default ChatGPT model for free users 鈥 and found that it can struggle with basic comprehension. For example, I asked it 鈥淲hich is bigger? 4.9 or 4.11,鈥 and it answered: 鈥淲hen comparing version-like numbers, 4.11 is bigger than 4.9.鈥 I鈥檓 no math whiz, but even I know that 4.9 is greater than 4.11. However, by the way that the program responded, we can tell that it interpreted a simple math problem as a comparison of version-like numbers 鈥 for example, different versions of the same software. If I asked a human this (admittedly, poorly worded) question, they would likely answer 4.9 or request clarification on the context.

I asked Meta AI (another chatbot) a similar question and received a correct answer of 鈥4.9 is larger than 4.11.鈥 Because the model didn鈥檛 initially give me any of the rationale behind the answer, I asked a follow-up question of 鈥淲hy?鈥 for more insight. The model replied, 鈥淚n this case, 4.9 is larger than 4.11 by 0.78.鈥 In reality, we know that 4.9 is larger than 4.11 by 0.79.

While it is quite easy to break out a calculator and verify the math in this case, I wonder if simple errors like this can bleed into other areas of the LLMs, which can color responses and lead to further inaccuracies. For instance, I asked ChatGPT, 鈥淲hat has a greater atomic mass: Cerium or Praseodymium?鈥 The answer it gave, Cerium, was incorrect 鈥 although it did tell me the correct atomic masses for both elements (140.12 amu for Ce and 140.91 amu for Pr).

For now, relying on LLMs to do your job will almost certainly lead to problems. Still, these tools can be extremely helpful for specific tasks, like finding related references for a niche topic of interest or summarizing action items from a meeting transcript. Our Special Section on AI and Digitalization this month examines some of the more practical aspects of using AI. Articles review how and where chemical engineers can use LLMs effectively (pp. 19鈥25), how AI is being used for HAZOP revalidation studies (pp. 27鈥34), and how AI-driven digital twins represent a first foray into the industrial metaverse (pp. 36鈥41).

Although the AI systems of today are not yet ready to lead a robot uprising against humankind, their use in engineering processes and our day-to-day lives is very much inevitable in the coming decade.

Emily Petruzzelli, Editor-in-Chief

images

Copyright Permissions 

Would you like to reuse content from CEP Magazine? It鈥檚 easy to request permission to reuse content. Simply to connect instantly to licensing services, where you can choose from a list of options regarding how you would like to reuse the desired content and complete the transaction.

Features

Departments